Breast Pumps, pt 5 – Manual vs Electric.

In: My Reviews

4 Jun 2010

It’s a Tie folks!
Harmony 4 : 4 Lactaline

Medela Harmony Breastpump and Ameda Lactaline Personal Breastpump

I know I promised sooner, but it did take me this long to get a hang of my new toy. When you have a baby, experimenting is not really a luxury *bleh*

Anyhow here’s the verdict based on my personal experience. So take it with a pinch of salt. It might not be the same for everyone ;)

Manual Breast Pump
(Medela Harmony, RM211.65)

My Verdict: 4 star
Harmony gives me total control: 1) Speed/Cycle — How fast I choose to pump and 2) Suction — How strong the expression to be.

In moderation, I can empty my breast in 15 minutes if they are full. For both would be around 30-40 minutes or it can go up to an hour *yawns*

There are only 3 parts to assemble and wash. Harmony is quick and easy to use without any fuss for batteries or DC to relief a much needed engorgement.

The only drawback is the time required to pump both breast separately. And not forgetting a sore wrist if you are expressing 5-6x a day.

If so, electric would be a wiser choice. Which brings me to my next verdict below.

Electric Dual Breast Pump
(Ameda Lactaline Personal, RM754.60)

My Verdict: 4 star

Once you’ve mastered the 2 dials on the pump — Cycle & Suction — the control is yours. Before that, practice makes perfect!

It took me 2 weeks playing with the dials. I was only using it once a day during the 4am expression while I’m still half asleep. I was disappointedly wondering why my yield was so poor compared to Harmony. I only found out last week from Ameda’s Technician — thinking that the pump was faulty — that the suction I used was too gentle.

After gritting my teeth with a higher suction — it wasn’t that bad — I can get the same amount as Harmony with half the time! Because I can pump 2 together *duh*

Ironically though, I still prefer using it as a single pump. That way I can hold with 1 hand and massage with the other.

Obviously there are more parts in Lactaline compared to Harmony. What I do is — a lazy person’s roundabout — I keep 1 side sterilised, and the other as my use-wash-keep aside for quick relief pump. That way, I don’t need to worry about washing and sterilising every time.

For less than RM1000, you get a dual pump that can go single, batteries or DC operated, light and compact on the go. Definitely best deal in the house!

So if you have the budget, I would highly recommend Lactaline.

If you are deciding between manual and electric, Think long term!

For example: 1) When your baby is teething and direct latch on is painful, 2) When you go back to work and 3) You want to continue bottle feeding breast milk as long as possible. Not forgetting 4) You have developed a permanent sore wrist :P

All the above scenarios point to an electric breast pump. And a dual would be fantastic! ;)

Breast Pumps Sequels
Breast Pumps, pt 1 – The Research.
Breast Pumps, pt 2 – The Purchase.
Breast Pumps, pt 3 – My Verdict.
Breast Pumps, pt 4 – Ameda Lactaline Personal.
Breast Pumps, pt 5 – Manual vs Electric.



You Might Also Be Interested:
Breast Pumps, pt 3 – My Verdict.
Breast Pumps, pt 4 – Ameda Lactaline Personal.
Breast Pumps, pt 1 – The Research.
Breast Pumps, pt 2 – The Purchase.
Little Bean Sterilizer.

11 Responses to Breast Pumps, pt 5 – Manual vs Electric.

Avatar

linlin

June 4th, 2010 at 9:08 am

Finally, you get it to work.

Actually you don’t have to sterilize the parts each time you use it. I only sterilized it once a day. After you use it, keep the parts that is in contact with milk (breastshields, diaphgrams and valves) in a tupperware container and keep it in the fridge. When you need to pump, take it out from the fridge and use it again.

I have been practising this ever since I started using Ameda pump.

Avatar

mellomouse

June 4th, 2010 at 10:05 am

Lin

Yup finally got it to work! *embarrassed*

You mean I don’t wash it after using and just keep straight away into the fridge? Hmm… I trust you! :)

Avatar

linlin

June 4th, 2010 at 10:51 am

Yes, no need to wash the parts. Just put it inside the fridge. Make sure you wash and sterilize once a day. No need to throw away your EBM. Your milk is precious!!

Avatar

mellomouse

June 4th, 2010 at 12:37 pm

Lin

Got it! I always worry the pump and bottles are not sterilised enough. Like how fast would they be contaminated once removing from the steriliser?

I’m always getting nagged for throwing away my EBM. I know it is precious but storage is limited and Natey is going direct. I’ll continue to express and recycle each time my bottles are finished. So the EBM will always be as fresh as possible :)

Midwife advised not to keep topping up in the same bottle because our weather is hot. Bacteria can grow very fast when we remove from the freezer and adding different temperature EBM into existing frozen one.

I only express 2x a day — before sleep and at 4am. I only keep the latter because that’s the most yield. As for the rest of the day, I just pump to relief pressure so those I also feed the sink :P

Avatar

linlin

June 4th, 2010 at 1:24 pm

If you are lazy to sterilize the bottle, you can use the liners. You can pump directly into the liner. I always store my breastmilk to liners.

Here’s the link on how to store pump breastmilk directly into the liners.

Avatar

mellomouse

June 4th, 2010 at 3:13 pm

Lin

Ooo cool! This will come in handy when Natey isn’t latching on anymore. Definitely save space in the fridge. Thanks again! *muaks*

Avatar

linlin

June 4th, 2010 at 3:48 pm

Breastfeeding is hard, weaning is even harder!! :) Now I don’t know how to wean my gal off my breast. She needs it to fall asleep at night. She fight with me for my breast. :(

Avatar

mellomouse

June 4th, 2010 at 5:06 pm

Lin

Read this! A friend just shared and it is beautiful. Maybe you might reconsider weaning ;)

Avatar

May yee

June 6th, 2010 at 6:08 pm

Hi hi! I am expressing -10 mins each session for 4 times since Sophie is taking 2.5 onc each feed. I’m using specta7, the industrial breast pump, siliar to the machine used in the hospital… (expressed my milk on the 2nd day after surgery). I used madela electric single pump… It’s too slow, painful and noisy like a lawn mower!

Avatar

mellomouse

June 7th, 2010 at 11:24 am

May Yee

You are so blessed to have it easy! I hope Sophie will get to enjoy Mommy’s treasure soon. How is she doing? Recovered from jaundice yet?

Avatar

MAy Yee

June 18th, 2010 at 1:58 pm

She is still having her jaundice…. mild. Details you will read in the fb msg.

Comment Form

The Definition

mel⋅o⋅dra⋅mat⋅ic
[mel-uh-druh-mat-ik]

–adjective
1. of, like, or befitting melodrama.
2. exaggerated and emotional or sentimental; sensational or sensationalized; overdramatic.

–noun
3. melodramatics, melodramatic writing or behavior.

mouse
[n. mous; v. mouz]

–noun
1. any similar small animal of various rodent and marsupial families.
2. a quiet, timid person.
3. Slang. a girl or woman.

Peek ⋅ a ⋅ boo

Lilypie Pregnancy tickers

Lilypie Second Birthday tickers

PitaPata Dog tickers

Photobucket

Kuala Lumpur

Los Angeles

Archives

Categories

hits since Aug 2006
pairs of footprints visiting